Friday, July 31, 2009

commitment

Falling in love, I think, involves crossing a line. There's a vast divide between affection and love, or maybe between loving someone and being in love with someone. The very act of crossing that line has its paradoxes: in order to take interest in someone in a genuine way, you have to have your own ideas of what men or women should be like, but in order to fall in love, you have to be able to be able to allow that person to redefine what a person should be on the basis of what they are -- willingly and wholeheartedly. I'm aware that this kind of love is rare and that my definition isn't one most people share, but I still hold to it. The people I know whom I've believed were really in love were able to say, "She/he is it for me." And I've felt that way myself, so, "problem of others" aside, I know that it's possible for at least one person in the world.

Christ. Even writing this is wearing me out.

Anyway, it took me a while to wrap my head around that idea, and it didn't happen until long after it had actually happened to me. It came over me like a revelation and in the wake of it I discarded a lot of my ideas about ethics and obligation. I became something of a devotee of passion. And I started going to the opera with insane frequency. It really was like a conversion experience, as I told Joe. By the time I met my last boyfriend, I had been changed by my experiences enough to see things diffeerently. I knew from the start that he was going to leave, and soon, and that even if things went perfectly, I'd still end up alone in an empty city with a handful of photos and memories and not much else. Which is what happened. And it's entirely my fault. I wasn't being shortsighted at the time; I was completely aware of the consequences. I'd just had so many empty flings in the period leading up to that (one of which I was returning from when we met, on the subway to Lincoln Center) -- and I liked him so much.

So I let myself go. My friends sat me down, a mere week into that relationship, and tried to warn me away from it. "I know what it's like to want to spend all day in bed with someone," Juan said kindly, "And it's amazing. But you have to realize that you're the vulnerable one here. He's leaving and you're not." I think he actually grabbed me to show how firmly he felt that. "Yes," I said quietly, "but this kind of compulsion is so rare and so sublime -- so yes, if I didn't take this chance, I'd probably be a lot safer. But for what? Who would I be if I ignored this kind of call? Is safety really worth that price?"

He looked me in the eye and saw, I guess, that there was no stopping me. So I did it. And it went as well as it possibly could have. I walked right up to the line and looked over the edge and felt the swelling of what I can only describe as vertigo, the thrill and horror of knowing exactly what you want and knowing that what you have is real, is huge, is the stuff of life... I'm not poet enough to put it into words. I hope you'll understand me anyway.

And then it ended and I was left, predictably, alone, shaken up, and deeply wary of the idea of love. I wasn't skeptical, but I was aware more than ever of the potential pain and hopelessness you open yourself to when you fall for someone. I'd never been dumped or even left, really, before then (although I'd been turned down, stood up, et cetera like anyone else). I'd planned to visit him in his country, but when I thought about going through the whole thing -- looking into his eyes again, and then, again, being unable to -- I couldn't bring myself to do it. From the perspective of the person left behind, I felt that it would have been breaking my own heart, and I couldn't do it. So I stayed. It hurt even more because I understood that he'd resent my staying and might doubt my reasons -- we couldn't really miss each other together after that, if that makes any sense. I think that would have helped me.

So after some pathological butterfly-like behavior (cross-pollinating, let's say) I let a friend set me up with someone. And had a terrific, romantic first date with him, during which I chain-smoked and acted like a social alien. And then avoided his subsequent (inexplicable) calls and emails. And then finally went out with him again. And again, and again after that. And then came clean to him about the ex, the other guys, and my conflicted feelings. And got dumped on my ass. And realized that despite being unready in some ways, I really did want to date him. And told him so.

Now, about four months later, we're still going out, and it's still exciting, and I see him most days of the week and things are lovely and fun and genuine, and we talk about this stuff sometimes, although not too much, at my request.

The thing is, I don't want to forget. That's what it means to cross the line, to me. I see it as similar to an interpetation of the Meno that Professor Mann offered up last year -- it's possible that by remaining true to an ideal, even in the face of an interlocutor as formidable as Socrates, you not only prove the substance of the ideal but give it that substance. I want to live the kind of life where ideals have substance. My attitudes towards my career, my friendships, and my love affairs all reflect that value, when you look closely. And if I can forget something that meant so much to me -- that nearly meant everything to me -- what kind of a person will I have become?

On the other hand, as S said, "a person only has so much room in their heart." I'm 20 years old. I haven't been doing this for very long. I can't keep remembering this way, carrying the past into the present. I don't know how to keep my life full of those kinds of transcendent passions without being devastated by them. In a way, I was lucky that time -- another month and I'd probably have been destroyed.

Another reason I'm holding back, I think, is that this new relationship, despite its appearances, isn't as recklessly passionate as my last was; I get the feeling sometimes that we're both a bit traumatized, holding back somehow. Maybe it's easier to forget the past when the present is equally forceful. And I'm sure it's unfair for me to paradoxically refrain from forgetting the past because I can't forget the past, which is what I suspect is happening. I mean, it's just counterproductive.

I get the feeling, from trying to talk to him, that some of these problems go away with age. Or maybe they're just in my head. I hope so. Because I have to resolve this one way or another in order to have the kind of life I know I want, and I don't feel any closer to figuring it out, even after writing all this.

Ugh. Everything's so messy and complicated! I should probably take Aristotle's advice and just buy a Rabbit and some opera LPs and hope for a quiet death.

No comments: